Varities and types question

3 posts • viewed 109 times

I am trying to understand Numista's position on types and varieties.

 

Recently I tried to enter a 1965 Canadian one cent coin.

N#432

 

Before I could tell Numista I had one, I needed to figure out which of four varieties I owned.  I am not a collector of Canadian cents, so it was a bit of work to figure out the shape of a particular serif and my bead size.  The was no way to say “1965 don't care”.

 

I also tried to enter an ancient Greek coin, from the town of Leukas.  In this case there were three types:

N#143914

N#143924

N#143947

 

Those three types aren’t linked.  I realize they come actual coins in catalogs: SNG-B Lock, SNG Cop, and HGC.  I see them as varieties:

 

Obverse: Gorgon with tongue protruding vs Gorgon with no tongue

Reverse: Pegasus flying left vs Pegasus flying right; Pegasus with straight wings vs Pegasus with curved wings.

 

Because they aren’t linked as a single Numista N#, it is difficult for the collector to know what the criteria is to decide which coin.  Because Numista doesn’t report population, only percentages, we won’t know which varieties are common and which are scarce.

 

The type “gorgon/Pegasus” actually occurs at a number of ancient Greek mints that were colonies of Corinth.  The mints are: Leukas, Medeon / Medion, Corinth, and “tribal imitation”.

 

The problem is that some catalogs, such as SNG-B Lock and SNG Cop represent actual coins in collections, and other catalogs such as HGC do not.  Is there a way to say my coin is an unlisted variety of the type, because it differs in some small way?

 

For the first time I entered a photograph of my coin.  It is a private photograph.  Is there a way to make it public?

esnible

I am trying to understand Numista's position on types and varieties.

 

Recently I tried to enter a 1965 Canadian one cent coin.

N#432

 

Before I could tell Numista I had one, I needed to figure out which of four varieties I owned.  I am not a collector of Canadian cents, so it was a bit of work to figure out the shape of a particular serif and my bead size.  The was no way to say “1965 don't care”.

 

Since it's a coin you entered in your collection, you just make a private comment “variety not identified”. The problem only comes if you get one for your doubles list some time in the future, where a variety collector would like to know, precisely, what you have.

Globetrotter
Coin varieties in French:
https://monnaiesetvarietes.numista.com

 

I also tried to enter an ancient Greek coin, from the town of Leukas.  In this case there were three types:

N#143914

N#143924

N#143947

 

Those three types aren’t linked.  I realize they come actual coins in catalogs: SNG-B Lock, SNG Cop, and HGC.  I see them as varieties:

 

Obverse: Gorgon with tongue protruding vs Gorgon with no tongue

Reverse: Pegasus flying left vs Pegasus flying right; Pegasus with straight wings vs Pegasus with curved wings.

 

Because they aren’t linked as a single Numista N#, it is difficult for the collector to know what the criteria is to decide which coin.

There are not a single Numista N# because are different coins, not varieties (I think).

 

I sent modification request for add information in titles and link to similar coins.

Wanted & swap list (euro coins & world coins, exonumia and banknotes circulated) https://goo.gl/AQjfKp - I have euro & world CC coins for swap.

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 08:09.