MPCC: Voting D 5 CLOSED

19 posts

» Quick access to the last post

dptashny
Closed account
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 00:06 #
Posted: #
Category: North and South America

Mexico- 8 Reales (Federal Coinage)

VS
United States- ½ Dollar (Vermont Sesquicentennial)
torontokuba
Closed account
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 00:28 #
Posted: #
Great, finally I'm forced to choose between two worthy opponents. This one is tough. I think the commemorative disability is obvious, 1 it is.
Dr. Math
Closed account
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 00:41 #
Posted: #
#2 dat cat.
Mark240590
Closed account
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 00:59 #
Posted: #
Number one - I want an all colonial coin final ha !
eminem
Joined: 9 Ocak 2012
Posts: 810
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 01:33 #
Posted: #
Number 2, love commemoratives and silver, but I do like the 'libertad' hat on coin one
Numista referee for Canada and Estonia.
pnightingale
Joined: 27 Tem 2011
Posts: 5383
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 01:35 #
Posted: #
#1

For the patina.
Non illegitimis carborundum est.  Excellent advice for all coins.
Make Numismatics Great Again!  
KennyG
Joined: 25 Nis 2010
Posts: 5285
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 02:11 #
Posted: #
Number 2 is a pretty nice coin.

The toning on number 1 is really beautiful, but the engravings on that US coin outmatch the Mexican eagle.
Kenny

- Verifying your Asian and British-territorial coins everyday with the best quality photos and the best information.

Check out my Facebook, Kenneth Gucyski.
smoked_caramel
Joined: 3 Tem 2012
Posts: 1640
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 02:34 #
Posted: #
Another tough one, but I'll got with #2 mainly because it is better grade.
elvis123
Joined: 3 Nis 2012
Posts: 1229
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 02:34 #
Posted: #
#1 because of the beautifully toned silver.
redsmithstudios
Joined: 20 Ara 2010
Posts: 3064
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 03:46 #
Posted: #
#2

almost went for #1 but the cat is so well sculpted.

  
Taking a break from swapping for a while, but still interested in pre 1799 Spanish coins, I will make time for that!

Looking for pre 1783 coins
terchua
Joined: 30 Eyl 2012
Posts: 87
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 04:17 #
Posted: #
#2, coz the cat stands out
scceda
Joined: 25 Eyl 2011
Posts: 564
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 08:41 #
Posted: #
2 for nice design, the Mexican coin is boring
fliegendehollander
Joined: 22 Haz 2010
Posts: 492
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 10:53 #
Posted: #
1
Denn alles Fleisch, es ist wie Gras
apuking Catalogue referee
Joined: 31 Ekim 2012
Posts: 9391
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 11:56 #
Posted: #
hard one I do love both but I will say #1 love the oxidised patination and the eagle
If you like coins, medals and tokens with ship motives follow my new instagram account with regular updates @numisnautiker
From time to time I sell some coins on Ebay make sure to follow me @apuking on Ebay.
Sanjuro2020
Joined: 15 Ocak 2012
Posts: 142
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 13:21 #
Posted: #
#2 I just love the American commemorative half dollars and the Vermont is one of my favorites. The Mexican coin is a beauty as well no doubt.
bam777
Joined: 5 Ağu 2011
Posts: 4414
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 14:12 #
Posted: #
2, a cool commemorative.
ditodoro1
Joined: 13 Şub 2012
Posts: 24
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 17:54 #
Posted: #
#2 because it's just more attractive overall.
kuba997
Joined: 18 Şub 2011
Posts: 426
Posted: 28 Kas 2012, 18:46 #
Posted: #
2
coins coins coins
Joined: 8 Ocak 2011
Posts: 52
Posted: 29 Kas 2012, 16:21 #
Posted: #
No. 1, I do not like that Mexican animal...
Reply
Forum »

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 15:19.