Is anyone able to identify if this coin contains a minting error, like a cud, or something else? I found this nearly 40 years ago either in circulation or at a flea market in Canada.
You're explanation seems the most likely cause. It looked like there could be extra metal in the damaged area but its possible a deep gouge could have smeared metal into a ridge-like shape. There are other little areas on the bottom of the coin with similar galling, too.