While researching a question posed today I came across this item:
It is nominally a counterstamp on an 1871 coin, but the pictured coin doesn't make sense to me. The obverse is dated 1871 but I only see the reverse on coins dated 1877 and later. (I looked in Numista and Krause.)
Am I missing something?
If not, should we update the listing to say is it a countermark over a counterfiet? Or remove the reverse image and description?