Move to undetermined [solved]

8 posts • viewed 71 times

This message aims at: requesting the modification of a piece of exonumia in the catalogue

Status: Done
Upvotes: 1
Downvotes: 0

Could you please move all the members on line #260544 of the following page to undetermined and delete the line

Token - Ball O matic (Niles, Michigan) - United States – Numista

 

I have added Variety 1 and Variety 2 lines for the Flat and Convex patterns. Hope to have a more detailed explanation of the varieties soon.

 

Thank you

Referee for Exonumia from United States

You don't need to create delete the indetermined line.

As nobody gets an example of the line variety 1 or variety 2, just add the comment “variety 1” to the first line, suppress the current line “variety 1” and let only the line "variety 2"

So you can close this request.

 

Then "Variety1" was already discribed as “Flat pattern” which is not a so clear description but anyway we can keep it.

The only thing I see flat is the straight triangular flag that's why I suggest:

Variety 1 - Flat pattern (straight flag, small RWM, fine reedings and pearls, BallOmatic far from rim)

 

And:

Variety 2 - Convex Pattern (curved flag, big RWM, bold reedings and pearls, BallOmatic close to rim)

Just suppress the comment of my example.

I add description of varieties in the coin fil but adapt it as you want.

Thanks

Referee of south atlantic islands

Frenchlover

You don't need to create delete the indetermined line.

I am not asking to create or delete an undetermined line since all pages already have that options. I am asking that all members be moved to undetermined so that they may be able to select the variety they have since it was not an option to them when they entered it into their collection their first time. It would be wrong to assume all of them have the variety 1 without giving them the choice.

Referee for Exonumia from United States

It might be understood as it exists some tokens with undermined features. Usually we don't had such undetermined lines unless for old unreadable coins or spanish dates in stars.

Usually we put all collectors in the first line and if by chance he cares, he modifies :)

Referee of south atlantic islands

Frenchlover

It might be understood as it exists some tokens with undermined features. Usually we don't had such undetermined lines unless for old unreadable coins or spanish dates in stars.

Usually we put all collectors in the first line and if by chance he cares, he modifies :)

When you refer to "we" you may mean “I”. Because there are many requests from different referees in the forums to move members to undetermined.

Referee for Exonumia from United States

Like a king, I say we instead of I :)

From our point when there are two varieties, there must be only two lines.

We may ask  to an Exonumia master referee their opinion.

Referee of south atlantic islands

There will only be two lines unless you've been moved to Undetermined. Like so:

What you will see:

What I will see:

Bonjour,

Effectivement, maintenant que les 2 variétés sont distinguables, la ligne 260544 est supprimée et les membres dirigés vers « indeterminé ». 

C’est aux membres désormais de choisir leur variété. 
…un envoi de message MP serait l’idéal afin qu’ils soient tous au courant qu’ils peuvent désormais choisir une des variétés. Peut-être un travail pour Mr Robot?

X @NumisMedal
Status changed to Done (Polette, 4 Ağu 2025, 11:21)

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 22:45.