Same coin pages [solved]

6 posts • viewed 69 times

This message aims at: requesting the modification of a coin in the catalogue

Status: Done
Upvotes: 0
Downvotes: 1
Coinwalla
Joined: 4 Ağu 2023
Posts: 1009
Posted: 8 Ağu 2025, 22:24 #
Posted: #

According to Goron and goenka‘s book both coin pages are the same coin gg q75

keep:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces396473.html


 

 Delete : N#362743

Arnav
maneeshks
Joined: 20 May 2021
Posts: 108
Posted: 9 Ağu 2025, 02:39 #
Posted: #

Neither of the KM references on the two coin pages, i.e., # 8.2 and 8.3, are for a 1 Falus: 

#8.2 is for ½ falus and #8.3 is for ¾ falus

2. 1 Falus - Abdullah Qutb Shah (/pieces362743) has the correct GG ref# Q73 even though the weight at 9.6g is below the 10-11g range given in GG.

 

GG# Q75 suggested by the OP is a 10-11g Falus of Abu'l Hasan Qutb Shah, and I am not seeing the similarity of the two coin pages with this coin. As mentioned above, one is correctly classified as GG# Q73.

Coinwalla
Joined: 4 Ağu 2023
Posts: 1009
Posted: 9 Ağu 2025, 04:41 #
Posted: #

oh, sorry i meant ggq73 :)

Arnav
Coinwalla
Joined: 4 Ağu 2023
Posts: 1009
Posted: 10 Ağu 2025, 08:31 #
Posted: #

they are the same according to gg

Arnav
Coinwalla
Joined: 4 Ağu 2023
Posts: 1009
Posted: 12 Ağu 2025, 01:13 #
Posted: #

the weights are also the same

Arnav
Coinwalla
Joined: 4 Ağu 2023
Posts: 1009
Posted: 13 Ağu 2025, 06:07 #
Posted: #

bump

Arnav
Status changed to Done (tdziemia, 14 Ağu 2025, 02:24)
Reply
Forum »

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 07:14.