3 Prussian Thalers for grading

I picked up these 3 Thalers for $1 above spot price today. I would like to hear some opinions on their grades. I have added my guess at the grades for your amusement.


Nr 1 - 1 Thaler - Friedrich Wilhelm IV (https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces47416.html) - VG with scratches



Nr 2 - 1 Vereinsthaler - Friedrich Wilhelm IV (https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces29656.html) - F


Nr 3 - 1 Thaler - Wilhelm I Coronation (https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces16991.html) - VG


Thank you for your time.

VG
F
F+

Nice coins Spookie I really don't know that much about these coins. They are a great find . I think I will go with bam777 He a smart one. Good find, nice coins, If they did not put a smile on your face send to me . No you enjoy them my friend. May you find more great coins.

- F
VF
F+

and pretty.

I agree with Phil's grades. In particular, I think #2 is definitely better than F. The ear is fully defined, good hair detail, lots of detail on the bird, etc.

Thank you all.