Design contest for the 2017 Numista token

97 posts

» Quick access to the last post

Bonjour,

Following the first announcement by chomp-master, the time has come to bring the idea of a 2017 Numista token to the next level. 2017 is a very special year, since Numista will have it's 10th anniversary in March.

The organization will be very similar to the last edition in 2003 (read the Numisdoc article):
  • Everyone can submit a design for the future token
  • A first selection of 5 designs will be done by a restricted panel (Jarek, chomp-master and me for this year)
  • All Numista members will be able to vote to select the final design

Rules of the contest are very simple:
  • Designs should be submitted before the 25th of January, 2017
  • To submit your design, please send it to Jarek, chomp-master or me
  • Submissions should include a design for the obverse and the reverse. The edge will be smooth.
  • Be creative and express your vision of Numista :)

The author of the winning design can include his or her initials on the token and he or she will receive 2 tokens of each version (copper and silver).
YEESSS!! Can't wait!
I would be very interested to try my hand at this !
Great! Let's come up with the denomination for the coin? 1 Xavier, for example? Suitable for Exonumia.:)
Quote: "Cyrillius"​Great! Let's come up with the denomination for the coin? 1 Xavier, for example? Suitable for Exonumia.:)
​I imagine if there is a denomination, it should be "10"
The 10th anniversary might also coincide with the hundred thousandth entry in the catalog :8D
Referee of south atlantic islands
15 000 new entries until March? :° That would be quite tough.

Given we have approximately 2000 new entries every month, we would have to make 7,5 months work in 3.

Well, if anyone would like to start - https://en.numista.com/forum/topic54146.html#p448561
Catalogue administrator
My last entry is n°99572
Referee of south atlantic islands
Ok, but total number of coins and tokens stands at 85616.
Catalogue administrator
Funny to see that 14-15% of coin files were deleted as duplicates or refused files.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
We would need to work really hard to make it 100.000 coins and tokens by March. By the way, what's the exact date? The 1st of March or what?
ROMA AETERNA
Not sure, modification history works from 2008 only.
Catalogue administrator
There was no official release date. I think we can consider the registration date of the first user (besides me).
So let's choose the 7th of March, 2007 as the official birthday of Numista ;)
Quote: "Xavier"​There was no official release date. I think we can consider the registration date of the first user (besides me).
​So let's choose the 7th of March, 2007 as the official birthday of Numista ;)

Well, 100 000 coins before 7th of March look like mission impossible, but anyway we need to do our best to make the catalog better.
ROMA AETERNA
Quote: "Xavier"​There was no official release date. I think we can consider the registration date of the first user (besides me).
​So let's choose the 7th of March, 2007 as the official birthday of Numista ;)
​Just out of Curiosity, do you know who was the first official user (apart from yourself of course Xavier)?
Quote: "pcarey2003"
Quote: "Xavier"​There was no official release date. I think we can consider the registration date of the first user (besides me).
​​So let's choose the 7th of March, 2007 as the official birthday of Numista ;)
​​Just out of Curiosity, do you know who was the first official user (apart from yourself of course Xavier)?
​Google search bot?
Catalogue administrator
Move your brushes, soon the end !
Referee of south atlantic islands
Quote: "pcarey2003"
Quote: "Xavier"​There was no official release date. I think we can consider the registration date of the first user (besides me).
​​So let's choose the 7th of March, 2007 as the official birthday of Numista ;)
​​Just out of Curiosity, do you know who was the first official user (apart from yourself of course Xavier)?
​Each user have ID, you can see it when viewing user's profile. Xavier have ID = 2, if you start to increase ID number in url you will find that first existing ID is 20. And here the user: https://en.numista.com/echanges/profil.php?id=20
Which font is used in the Numista logo?
I translate through Yandex. All languages are welcome.
Quote: "Megas"
Quote: "pcarey2003"

Quote: "Xavier"​There was no official release date. I think we can consider the registration date of the first user (besides me).
​​​So let's choose the 7th of March, 2007 as the official birthday of Numista ;)
​​​Just out of Curiosity, do you know who was the first official user (apart from yourself of course Xavier)?
​​
​​Each user have ID, you can see it when viewing user's profile. Xavier have ID = 2, if you start to increase ID number in url you will find that first existing ID is 20. And here the user: https://en.numista.com/echanges/profil.php?id=20
​...who has been totally inactive for ten years.

What about the oldest account that has logged in within the last 90 days?
Quote: "Cerulean"​​​...who has been totally inactive for ten years.

​What about the oldest account that has logged in within the last 90 days?
https://en.numista.com/echanges/profil.php?id=108
Quote: "Megas"​​​Each user have ID, you can see it when viewing user's profile. Xavier have ID = 2, if you start to increase ID number in url you will find that first existing ID is 20. And here the user: https://en.numista.com/echanges/profil.php?id=20

Never realised this, thanks Megas for the information and the links to the longest members.
Broge (#24) was the first user to make any contributions whatsoever, so maybe March 9th would be a better date for the 10th anniversary.
.
Doesn't anybody know what font the Numista logo is in?
I translate through Yandex. All languages are welcome.
What is the process of designing a coin on the computer? Where does one start? If you have an excellent idea, but cannot convey it to computer, what can be done?
Can a jewel or two be used in the design? Where can I get a set of die stamps made to order? I want to make coins for personal use, promotions, etc.,..Anybody?
Thank you, yes sir, no sir, and please.
Here is a possible link for the process.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=508380
And you can create your own design with this website, even thought it's a little bit rough finish
Referee of south atlantic islands
Hi all,

I have just finished my design and it is only missing the initials

Can we include a name in really small letter instead of the initials?
If not, how many initials maximum can we use?
I'm really hoping to win this competition. Please let me know what you think about my design. Send me a PM with any thoughts.

McKay
Quote: "Croft89coffey"​I'm really hoping to win this competition. Please let me know what you think about my design. Send me a PM with any thoughts.

​I'll register this design, however please notice the missing letter in French "ECHANGE SANS FRONTIERES"
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "cheis"​Hi all,

​I have just finished my design and it is only missing the initials

​Can we include a name in really small letter instead of the initials?
​If not, how many initials maximum can we use?
​I guess a full name can be added. Like the French coin by Georges Guiraud. But if the name is very huge, initials may be better (like in Italy with a 3-part name) or only the last name (like in some French coins: Lagriffoul, Jimenez...) with/without the first name initial(s). It's up to you.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "Croft89coffey"​I'm really hoping to win this competition. Please let me know what you think about my design. Send me a PM with any thoughts.

​I really like the globe side . With all the different currencies . I cannot identify a few of them. Though I don't see the Indian rupee symbol (lol should I've offended ! hehe )

Just as constructive critique, given the token is only 30mm, will the Symbols come out clear ? (That was the problem I wrestled with in my own design).
For the other side, I'm only concerned that rather than "exchanging", one hand putting coins in another looks more like "donating" or "begging".

It's be great if you open a new thread and write down some points about your thought process and the reasons for the various design elements. I'm sure a lot of us would appreciate your effort even more when we get a glimpse of it from behind the scenes as it were. For instance I'm curious how you chose the currency symbols and why the Atlantic Ocean side of the word (why not the Indian Ocean ?)

Best of luck to both of us !
Quote: "chomp-master"
Quote: "cheis"​Hi all,
​​
​​I have just finished my design and it is only missing the initials
​​
​​Can we include a name in really small letter instead of the initials?
​​If not, how many initials maximum can we use?
​​I guess a full name can be added. Like the French coin by Georges Guiraud. But if the name is very huge, initials may be better (like in Italy with a 3-part name) or only the last name (like in some French coins: Lagriffoul, Jimenez...) with/without the first name initial(s). It's up to you.
Hi chomp-master,

Thank you for the reply. I will go with my last last name ( Cheis ) because oddly as it may be it matters for the concept of the design. To whom should we submit the design? Here to this topic, to you to Xavier?
I'm really hoping to win this competition. Please let me know what you think about my design. Send me a PM with any thoughts.

McKay
Quote: "cheis"
Quote: "chomp-master"

Quote: "cheis"​Hi all,
​​​
​​​I have just finished my design and it is only missing the initials
​​​
​​​Can we include a name in really small letter instead of the initials?
​​​If not, how many initials maximum can we use?
​​​I guess a full name can be added. Like the French coin by Georges Guiraud. But if the name is very huge, initials may be better (like in Italy with a 3-part name) or only the last name (like in some French coins: Lagriffoul, Jimenez...) with/without the first name initial(s). It's up to you.
​Hi chomp-master,

​Thank you for the reply. I will go with my last last name ( Cheis ) because oddly as it may be it matters for the concept of the design. To whom should we submit the design? Here to this topic, to you to Xavier?
​No matter there or in any PM (Xavier, Jarcek or mine).
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "Croft89coffey"​I'm really hoping to win this competition. Please let me know what you think about my design. Send me a PM with any thoughts.

​Is that the same drawing? I asked you to rewrite in the French lettering FRONTIERES
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Sorry. That was an accident. Thank you so much for pointing that out. I can't believe I missed that. I'll try to edit it as best I can. Thank you.
McKay
Please have a look at my entry and provide any feedback either by PM or by reply to this post:
https://en.numista.com/forum/topic56521.html

Here is my updated reverse side with the correct spelling. Thanks for catching that!
McKay
How many submissions did you receive, and when do we get to see the finalists?
I think maybe a set of tokens might be a good idea.
Denominations: 1, 100, 200, 300, 400
When somebody hits these targets with their number of countries, they can order the token. Make a new set every year so that the token can serve as a memento. Only make as many as there are members at these levels such that the tokens themselves will gain in value and will be traded here on the site. Who knows, maybe in 2035 when the site has 4 million members, the 2018-400 country token will be worth more than gold!
I translate through Yandex. All languages are welcome.
14 designs are in the game now. Maybe somebody sent it right before deadline, so there might be more.

In the few days you will see the finalists. B)
Catalogue administrator
Quote: "Jarcek"​14 designs are in the game now. Maybe somebody sent it right before deadline, so there might be more.

​In the few days you will see the finalists. B)
​I believe the deadline passed, "Designs should be submitted before the 25th of January, 2017."
But there are three of us getting them, and I am not sure if Xavier or Chompmaster got some other designs and not yet reported them.
Catalogue administrator
I didn't receive any last-minute design, only last-minute updates of current applications.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "Frenchlover"​And you can create your own design with this website, even thought it's a little bit rough finish


​It's in german. I would only be guessing. I like some of its visual aspects.
Quote: "philwrr"​I think maybe a set of tokens might be a good idea.
​Denominations: 1, 100, 200, 300, 400
​When somebody hits these targets with their number of countries, they can order the token. Make a new set every year so that the token can serve as a memento. Only make as many as there are members at these levels such that the tokens themselves will gain in value and will be traded here on the site. Who knows, maybe in 2035 when the site has 4 million members, the 2018-400 country token will be worth more than gold!
​Bad idea.
Quote: "Bohannon"
Quote: "Frenchlover"​And you can create your own design with this website, even thought it's a little bit rough finish
​​
​​
​​
​​It's in german. I would only be guessing. I like some of its visual aspects.
Try it like this:
https://translate.google.pt/translate?sl=de&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=pt-PT&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.onlinewahn.de%2Fgenerator%2Fm-maker.htm&edit-text=&act=url

To get a site translated you can use the Google translator. Just paste in the site address and choose the original language and the language to be translated into.
It would be nice to see all the designs that were submitted posted where.
Even if it was only after the end of the contest.
I don't know about the others but I am very curious about the various designs.
Maybe you could even create a sticky post on the forum or a page dedicated to the 2 contests.
Quote: "cheis"​It would be nice to see all the designs that were submitted posted where.
​Even if it was only after the end of the contest.
​I don't know about the others but I am very curious about the various designs.
​Maybe you could even create a sticky post on the forum or a page dedicated to the 2 contests.
​I second that motion!
McKay
I designed it....pls have a look
Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector
Please give me some advice or your thoughts about my design :wiz:
Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector
Quote: "Sayan"​I designed it....pls have a look
​I think Xavier Uncle Loves French Language so I added the french in background.....Manteau Des Bras De Xavier.... Does it looks good?
Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector

Please send me your thoughts in my Pm or on this page Please..... :D
Best Regards
Sayan Biswas
Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector
Quote: "Sayan"
​​I think Xavier Uncle Loves French Language so I added the french in background.....Manteau Des Bras De Xavier.... Does it looks good?



Referee of south atlantic islands
Quote: "Frenchlover"
Quote: "Sayan"
​​​I think Xavier Uncle Loves French Language so I added the french in background.....Manteau Des Bras De Xavier.... Does it looks good?


​​

Why are You laughing french lover?

Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector
Is my design so bad to be laughed at? :snif:
Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector
He's mocking your word-by-word translation, showing you that even Google does better.

To be serious, I'm sorry but your design was submitted after the deadline, and we already started to review all applications.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "Sayan"
​Please send me your thoughts in my Pm or on this page Please..... :D
​Best Regards
​Sayan Biswas
​apart from the language you have real skill ! Congratulations on your artwork !!
I confirm what did ashlobo says, your artistic skills are on a high level.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "Sayan"​Please give me some advice or your thoughts about my design :wiz:
​I'm sorry, you're a little late. But I like your approach!

(Some French are also not very good use of Google-translator ;))
:o Is the deadline over?
:x I am sad....... So sorry for posting after deadline....
Cant I take part in the competition even if I cry? (just kidding)
Now, Can I not take part?
Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector
here's another one
Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector
Quote: "Sayan":o Is the deadline over?
:x I am sad....... So sorry for posting after deadline....
​Cant I take part in the competition even if I cry? (just kidding)
​Now, Can I not take part?
​Lol, sorry, numista is a global forum...it doesn't work on Indian standard time...a deadline is there for a reason ;)

I would say next time, take it more seriously and definitely seek feedback from others to correct the language and give some constructive criticism eg drop "King Xavier" lol ... Although I'm not one for heraldics... I can see so much potential in your design. It could have indeed been a winner.... and mind you, I've also entered the contest!
I understand..... next time I will post at correct time.... But I HAVE TO WAIT 4 YEARS?!??! :8D
Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector
Quote: "Sayan"​I understand..... next time I will post at correct time.... But I HAVE TO WAIT 4 YEARS?!??! :8D
​I don't know if they will do a 14th Anniversary of Numista lol... but I'm sure in another couple years there might be occasion to celebrate something else.
Quote: "Croft89coffey"​I'm really hoping to win this competition. Please let me know what you think about my design. Send me a PM with any thoughts.

​​:o beautiful... Very nice job!!
good luck! ;)
Quote: "Cyrillius"
Quote: "Sayan"​Please give me some advice or your thoughts about my design :wiz:
​​I'm sorry, you're a little late. But I like your approach!

​(Some French are also not very good use of Google-translator ;))
​As Frenchlover showed us, the terms "coat of arms" was well translated by Google.

I saw some people are speaking about Indian time... But Indian time is earlier than CET... The only isssue is it was 1 day late.

I'm asking my teammates about their advice for this late issue.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote
​I saw some people are speaking about Indian time... But Indian time is earlier than CET... The only isssue is it was 1 day late.
​lol, it's a running joke among Indians ... it's very common for people to be late for appointments... "Indian standard time" is a a euphemism for lateness or being slow
Didn't know this joke.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Do we know about when the voting will begin? I'm excited to see all the entries!
McKay
Today is admin meeting. Finalists will be revealed (and voted upon) afterwards. (This might take from few hours to few days)
Catalogue administrator
We received 15 designs for the contest. I would like to thank all the artists that participated to the contest. Chomp-master and I (with the inputs from Jarek) could not decide on only 5 designs, so we finally selected 6 finalists, which will take part in the vote to choose the final design.

Here are the 15 designs with results, sorted by date of submission.


  1. Selected





  2. Selected







  3. Selected

  4. Selected

  5. Selected







  6. Selected

I will contact the authors of the selected designs to suggest slight modifications, before the vote opens, probably during the week-end or early next week.

A special note for Sayan: I really liked your designs and, although they were submitted late, we considered them during the selection. We found the design very attractive but we didn't select it because of the theme of your design.
Quote: "Xavier"

​Double Obverse type? :O
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
I suppose there is a small error on the project n ° 2, they are two identical faces!?!
It seems to me that one of the faces should be this:

;)
Quote: "chomp-master"
​​Double Obverse type? :O
​Thanks, I edited my message.
Hello this is the final design of the obverse side .Can be read upward and downward in both languages.Yesterday succeed to design the arabic numbers.
I believed that all the (15)designs could participate to the contest and all the members worldwide vote.
I would like to see how many votes could take my and all the others designs.
Any way ,good luck to the 6 competitors that succeed to pass throw the committee.
As 5 designs become 6 also could become 15 :)
Thanks to administrators those gave us the opportunity to see our designs.
Thanks a lot Xavier Uncle as you liked my designs..... I will try me level best to compete next time and submit my design in correct time :wiz:
Best Of luck to selected designs
By Sayan :)
Sayan Biswas The Coin Collector
Quote: "5element"​I believed that all the (15)designs could participate to the contest and all the members worldwide vote.
​I would like to see how many votes could take my and all the others designs.

​Unfortunately a vote between 15 options would not be efficient.
That's why a preliminary selection is deemed necessary.
And, as a major fact, I've also been eliminated :snif:
Referee of south atlantic islands
Vote has started! Go vote: https://en.numista.com/vote/
Catalogue administrator
Interestingly, only two tokens have the logo Numista.
3 tokens. Look well.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Quote: "Cyrillius"​Interestingly, only two tokens have the logo Numista.
The ​Numista "N" is at the North Pole of the globe on my obverse design.
McKay
Surex.
Passing it, but also a lot of novice please consult thank you. My opinion. Each participant works as well. Just less historic.What is the ancient coins, ancient coins is representative of history, faith, culture. And to share, in a long time ago to complete a coin needs 6or7 race to complete. For example, the dragon on behalf of the Chinese, the eagle on behalf of the American and the meaning of peace.. The end have share only
I dont like it.

1. Exchage sisn frontieres looks like " Medicos sins fronteras" . It is well-known world humanitary organisation. words " sans frontieres" reminds first of all this organisation.

https://ru.msf.org/en/organization/introduction/who-is-msf

2. Two hands with a number of coins in one and one coin on other more looks like alms/donation, and not "exchange" .

3. nobody will understand what "2007-2017" means. Any commemorative token or medal must contain main legend - " 10 years since...." . Dont think only for ourr generation. Further ones also should understand the aim of this medal. " 10 years since the death of Mrs. Numista? " " 10 years since foundation os donating humanitarian organization NUMISTA"  ? or  ? . Legend should contain at least what NUMISTA is, and what means that ten years.

edited: - I think, www.numista.com should be on the medal in any case.

4. "12 world currencies" - are there only 12 currencies in the world?? Who voted for that currencies? why 12 and not 14? Dont you think that there were some reasons why these 12 were put on the medal, andnot other 12?

5. If we are contemporary numismatists / collector, - we should go step-by step with our time, and such design, with 99% of images and a few information is not in nowdays` trend. Today coins, medals andtokens design go by primitive way, very easy, just a few light images, and not such art-noveau medal

6. If we see lake Tanganyika on the African map, why we dont see lake Chad? If we see Madeira and azores, why we dont see Saint Thomas -prince islands?

7. Finally, I think medal needs a lot of work over it to swim in the numismatic river with other medals and tokens of pour time.

Thanks to author anyway, but I expected bit more from commemorative medal in 2017 .
And, sorry for my English
Yours,
D.
Seen on Facebook :love:
Referee of south atlantic islands
Any updates?
Oh, yes. Tokens already arrived, Xavier has them and we will be testing sale site soon.
Catalogue administrator
Tests are over and tokens are on sale.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Order placed :8D
Referee of south atlantic islands
Where do we go to order the token.
See Numista homepage-
Catalogue administrator
Thank you, tokens ordered.
I've received my token today :8D
It's wonderful :love:
Referee of south atlantic islands
There are now 48 silver tokens and 159 copper tokens left.
Here is the direct link to the shop: https://shop.numista.com/
Quote: "ashlobo"
Quote
​I saw some people are speaking about Indian time... But Indian time is earlier than CET... The only isssue is it was 1 day late.
​​lol, it's a running joke among Indians ... it's very common for people to be late for appointments... "Indian standard time" is a a euphemism for lateness or being slow
​in this "running joke" The Indians they are referring to are the native American Indians because we tend to do things in our own sweet time......

my two favorite quotes;
"good thing about going by Indian time is the fact that I'm never late!"
"if an Indian says he's going to do something, there is no need to remind him every 6 months"

(notice the date of original post to which I'm replying)
Quote: "War axe"
Quote: "ashlobo"

Quote
​​​I saw some people are speaking about Indian time... But Indian time is earlier than CET... The only isssue is it was 1 day late.
​​
​​​lol, it's a running joke among Indians ... it's very common for people to be late for appointments... "Indian standard time" is a a euphemism for lateness or being slow
​​in this "running joke" The Indians they are referring to are the native American Indians because we tend to do things in our own sweet time......

​my two favorite quotes;
​"good thing about going by Indian time is the fact that I'm never late!"
​"if an Indian says he's going to do something, there is no need to remind him every 6 months"

​(notice the date of original post to which I'm replying)
​hmm... I was referring to Indians from India, i cannot speak for native Americans (though it's interesting if that's something that exists among that community as well!)

» Forum policy

Used time zone is UTC+2:00.
Current time is 15:35.