Fat man dollar, 100% fake or 97% fake..? [solved]

Hello, all. In my opinion, buying a coin like this without a certificate of authenticity is the same as buying a lottery. The weight of this coin is 23.34 g. I hope someone says this is a mistake that often occurs in China coins.

Quote: "Mr-IQBAL001"In my opinion, buying a coin like this without a certificate of authenticity is the same as buying a lottery.
​

​Easy solution to that: don't buy "lottery tickets".

Normally I would ask you to provide clearer photos, as well of some of the reverse, but in this case I can say it's a straight up fake.

The year 8 (1919) only has the obverse type with seven characters above the portrait (incl. the last one "造"), so yours is an impossible type.

oh ... now i understand. this character "造" causes the weight of the coin to decrease

Quote: "Mr-IQBAL001"​oh ... now i understand. this character "造" causes the weight of the coin to decrease

​Um, no, that wasn't what I said.

That character is present on all Fat Man dollars of the date 1919 (中華民國八年造). There is no six character variant for this date, and it's not like the last character was worn off on your coin or anything; the character "年" is positioned in a different way than it should be on the real coin.

So it's not like the absence of the character makes the coin underweight, but it does indicate it is a fake that probably was made by a forger who didn't read up on this coin. It being underweight only hammers home a point that has already been proven.

Quote: "CassTaylor"​

Quote: "Mr-IQBAL001"​oh ... now i understand. this character "造" causes the weight of the coin to decrease

​​Um, no, that wasn't what I said.
​
​That character is present on all Fat Man dollars of the date 1919 (中華民國八年造). There is no six character variant for this date, and it's not like the last character was worn off on your coin or anything; the character "年" is positioned in a different way than it should be on the real coin.
​
​So it's not like the absence of the character makes the coin underweight, but it does indicate it is a fake that probably was made by a forger who didn't read up on this coin. It being underweight only hammers home a point that has already been proven.

​I think he was being facetious

Now I understand. You will definitely say this coin is also fake
because it should only have six characters. I hope this is a very rare coin

​Yup, now you understand; that's the essence of it!

(Basically the exact opposite of the mistake made by the forger for the first coin, which has six characters but is supposed to have seven.)

​How many of them do you want??

Did you try a magnet?

This coin does not react to magnets
You will never find a "1914" coin with seven characters.
I'm tired of looking for it. And don't find the same even though it's a fake coin

Quote: "Mr-IQBAL001"​This coin does not react to magnets
​You will never find a "1914" coin with seven characters.
​I'm tired of looking for it. And don't find the same even though it's a fake coin
​

​If you're willing to let your wallet take the hit:
https://www.ebay.fr/itm/China-Republic-Dollar-Yuan-Shih-Kai-Year-3-1914-FAT-MAN-DOLLAR/392087548659?hash=item5b4a3d32f3:g:j2UAAOSw6AVbVOiZ

Expect to pay at least 80 euro for a circulated example of a common date for this one, that's what someone told me.

all your opinions are the best. I will turn this coin into a silver ring

How, when it isn't silver?

Quote: "jimpop"​How, when it isn't silver?

​Pretty sure he was being facetious.

To repeat myself, here are the silver tests:
http://www.silvercoins.com/fake-silver-coins-14-ways-to-spot-counterfeits/
And some information:
https://www.thesprucecrafts.com/chinese-coin-counterfeiting-ring-4071202

Quote: "PetrusAscanus"​To repeat myself, here are the silver tests:
​http://www.silvercoins.com/fake-silver-coins-14-ways-to-spot-counterfeits/
​And some information:
​https://www.thesprucecrafts.com/chinese-coin-counterfeiting-ring-4071202

​the coin passed the magnetic test ,when I knock it with a screwdriver. his voice was clinking and long. I remember. The sound was like a bell from my grandfather's bicycle. When I was a kid
clinking like echoing
Coins are perfect for replacing bicycle bells

Quote: "Mr-IQBAL001"

Quote

​​the coin passed the magnetic test ,when I knock it with a screwdriver. his voice was clinking and long. I remember. The sound was like a bell from my grandfather's bicycle. When I was a kid
​clinking like echoing
​Coins are perfect for replacing bicycle bells

​ good idea!!

Quote: "PetrusAscanus"​

Quote: "Mr-IQBAL001"​

Quote

​​​the coin passed the magnetic test ,when I knock it with a screwdriver. his voice was clinking and long. I remember. The sound was like a bell from my grandfather's bicycle. When I was a kid
​​clinking like echoing
​​Coins are perfect for replacing bicycle bells
​
​

​​ good idea!!
​

this is sound, when 2 coins collide
​https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KU5C6xw-vzM&feature=youtu.be
https://youtu.be/SLGrqd9nkFk

The coins seem to be broken because of too often, collisions, I like the sound of these coins
and I tested it on ice. Ice melts very fast, in my opinion, this coin is very worthy of being made into a ring
because he is just a fake coin, it seems like that

Hello,

 

What year on coin? I can't find this coin by this year. It's fake coin? 

 

 

Year 1  年元 so fake.

If you have any more questions please start a new post and not tack onto a 7 year old one.